MilesToPass

Replacement duties for life insurance

Lesson 82 of 93 · All lessons · Up next: Nonforfeiture law →

Why replacement gets special rules

Most life insurance sales add coverage. A replacement does something different: it moves a client out of a contract they already own and into a new one. That can be the right advice — or it can cost the client contestability and suicide-clause protection that had already run, a lower age-based rate, and years of accumulated values, while paying the producer a fresh first-year commission. Because the client can rarely see that trade-off unaided, Texas regulates the process of a replacement rather than banning it.

What counts as a replacement

Treat the sale as a replacement whenever a new life insurance policy or annuity is applied for and, in connection with that same transaction, an existing life policy or annuity is:

  • lapsed, surrendered, or allowed to expire;
  • converted to reduced paid-up or extended-term insurance;
  • reduced in face amount, in benefit period, or in any other value;
  • amended so that benefits are cut; or
  • borrowed against or withdrawn from to help pay for the new contract.

Two features define it: the timing (the change to the old contract is part of the same buying decision) and the funding relationship (old values are paying for new coverage). It is still a replacement when the same company issues both contracts — that is an internal replacement — and it is still a replacement when the client, not the producer, suggested it.

The producer's four duties

A flow diagram showing who owes what to whom in a life insurance replacement. Across the top, a red banner states the overriding duty: no misrepresentation, no incomplete comparison, no twisting or churning, and the recommendation must be suitable for the client. On the left is a blue box labeled Producer, who signs and retains a copy. Arrow one goes up and right from the producer to a green box labeled Applicant or Owner, carrying the replacement notice and comparison; the applicant also signs and keeps a copy. Arrow two goes right from the producer to a blue box labeled Replacing insurer, carrying the signed forms submitted with the application. Arrow three goes right from the replacing insurer to a gold box labeled Existing insurer, carrying notice of the replacement, which lets the existing insurer respond and possibly conserve the policy. Arrow four loops down and left from the existing insurer to a green box at the bottom, delivering policy values and information. A downward arrow from the replacing insurer to that same bottom box shows the new policy being delivered. The bottom box reads: the owner reviews values, then examines and may return the new policy within the stated period.
Replacement duty flow: producer to applicant, producer to replacing insurer, replacing insurer to existing insurer, with information and a review period flowing back to the owner.

1. Disclose. Give the applicant the replacement notice and comparison your insurer supplies, no later than the time of application, and go through it with them. Both the applicant and you sign it; the applicant keeps a copy.

2. Document. Answer the replacement question on the application accurately, identify the existing insurer and policy, and send the signed notice and any comparison to the replacing insurer with the application. Keep your own copies for the retention period your insurer specifies.

3. Let the other insurer participate. Your paperwork is what allows the replacing insurer to notify the existing insurer, so the existing company can supply values and, if it wishes, try to conserve the business. Never route around that step by quietly surrendering the old policy first.

4. Don't distort. No misrepresentation, no half-finished comparison that shows the new premium but hides the lost values, and no twisting or churning. The recommendation must be suitable on the facts you gathered.

Practical sequencing

Do not cancel, surrender, or stop paying on the existing policy until the new policy has actually been issued, delivered, and is in force — health can change, and an underwriting decline after a surrender leaves the client uninsured. Point out the examination-and-return period stated in the replacement paperwork and on the new policy, and put the client's decision in writing.

If you are unsure whether a transaction is a replacement, complete the replacement forms anyway. Over-disclosing is never the violation.

Key terms

Sample questions

Which of the following situations should a Texas producer treat as a replacement transaction?

  • A client buys a new $250,000 term policy and continues paying premiums, unchanged, on all coverage she already owns.
  • A client's old policy lapsed for nonpayment three years ago and has nothing to do with today's application.
  • A client adds a child rider to a policy she already owns and applies for no new coverage.
  • A client borrows against the cash value of an existing whole life policy to pay the first premium on a new policy applied for in the same transaction.
Preview

This is a preview. The full lesson and question set require an active plan.

See pricing →

See where this fits: Texas exam outline and topic weights.